While I was working on my grFailOver POC, I have also done some additional parallel testing. One of them was to see how online DDL are executed inside a Group Replication cluster.

The online DDL feature provides support for instant and in-place table alterations and concurrent DML. Checking the Group Replication (GR) official documentation I was trying to identify if any limitation exists, but the only thing I have found was:

"Concurrent DDL versus DML Operations.  Concurrent data definition statements and data manipulation statements executing against the same object but on different servers is not supported when using multi-primary mode. During execution of Data Definition Language (DDL) statements on an object, executing concurrent Data Manipulation Language (DML) on the same object but on a different server instance has the risk of conflicting DDL executing on different instances not being detected."

This impacts only when you have a multi primary scenario, which is NOT recommended and not my case.

So in theory GR should be able to handle the online DDL without problems. 

My scenario :

I have two DCs and I am going to do actions on my DC1 and see how it propagates all over, and what impact I will have.

The test

To do the test I will run and insert from select. 

insert into windmills_test  select null,uuid,millid,kwatts_s,date,location,active,time,strrecordtype from windmills7 limit 1;

And a select, on my Primary node gr1, while on another connection execute the ALTER:

ALTER TABLE windmills_test ADD INDEX idx_1 (`uuid`,`active`), ALGORITHM=INPLACE, LOCK=NONE;

As you may have noticed I am EXPLICITLY asking for INPLACE and lock NONE. So in case MySQL cannot satisfy it should exit and not execute the command.

In the meantime on all other nodes I will run a check command to see WHEN my Alter is taking place.

Let us roll the ball:

On my Primary the command to insert the data

[root@gr1 grtest]# while [ 1 = 1 ];do da=$(date +'%s.%3N');/opt/mysql_templates/mysql-8P/bin/mysql --defaults-file=./my.cnf -uroot -D windmills_s -e "insert into windmills_test  select null,uuid,millid,kwatts_s,date,location,active,time,strrecordtype from windmills7 limit 1;" -e "select count(*) from windmills_s.windmills_test;" > /dev/null;db=$(date +'%s.%3N'); echo "$(echo "($db - $da)"|bc)";sleep 1;done

Again on Primary another session to execute the alter:

DC1-1(root@localhost) [windmills_s]>ALTER TABLE windmills_test ADD INDEX idx_1 (`uuid`,`active`), ALGORITHM=INPLACE, LOCK=NONE;

On other nodes to monitor when Alter will start:

while [ 1 = 1 ];do echo "$(date +'%T.%3N')";/opt/mysql_templates/mysql-8P/bin/mysql --defaults-file=./my.cnf -uroot -D windmills_s -e "show processlist;"|grep -i "alter";sleep 1;done

What happens:

Data is inserted by the loop.

Alter start, but I can still insert data in my table, and most important the data is propagated to all nodes of the DC1 cluster.

No alter action on the other nodes.

.559
.502
.446
.529
.543
.553
.533
.602
.458  <---- end of the alter locally

Once ALTER is complete on the local node (Primary) it is then executed (broadcast) to all the nodes participating in the cluster.

[ERROR 1205 (HY000) at line 1: Lock wait timeout exceeded; try restarting transaction <--- waiting for waiting for handler commit    No INSERTS are allowed

But write are suspended waiting for:

37411 | root            | localhost          | windmills_s | Query            |    19 | Waiting for table metadata lock                                 | insert into windmills_test  select null,uuid,millid,kwatts_s,date,location,active,time,strrecordtype

And eventually it will timeout.

The other point is that any write hangs until the slowest node had apply the ALTER:

It is important to note that all nodes, not only the PRIMARY remain pending waiting for the slow node:

The slowest drive all.

GR3:

11:01:28.649  48 system user windmills_s Query 171 altering table ALTER TABLE windmills_test ADD INDEX idx_1 (`uuid`,`active`), ALGORITHM=INPLACE, LOCK=NONE
11:01:29.674  48 system user windmills_s Query 172 waiting for handler commit ALTER TABLE windmills_test ADD INDEX idx_1 (`uuid`,`active`), ALGORITHM=INPLACE, LOCK=NONE

GR2

Start 11:00:14.438  18 system user windmills_s Query 97 altering table ALTER TABLE windmills_test ADD INDEX idx_1 (`uuid`,`active`), ALGORITHM=INPLACE, LOCK=NONE
Ends 11:02:00.107  18 system user windmills_s Query 203 altering table ALTER TABLE windmills_test ADD INDEX idx_1 (`uuid`,`active`), ALGORITHM=INPLACE, LOCK=NONE

Finally when the last node in the GR cluster has applied the ALTER, the writes will resume, and the Replica node on DC2 will start its ALTER operation on PRIMARY first, then on the other nodes.

Summarizing

We can say we have 3 phases. 

The first one is when the primary start to write and we have ONLINE operation:

Phase 2: is when the Primary ends the local operation and transmit the changes to the Secondary nodes:

Here all writes are locked by metalock.

Phase 3: is when all nodes have finalized the operation, the Alter is passed over replication channel (async replica) and metalock is removed.

1. Writes are executed on Primary
2. ALTER is executed on the Primary
   • DDL does not impact the write operation and respects the not blocking directive.
3. ALTER is completed on Primary and passed to all nodes
   • Meta lock is raised on nodes
4. ALL cluster waits for slowest node to complete
5. When all is done in the DC1 then the action is replicated to DC2
   • Goto point 2

 BUT!!! If the primary goes down, the cluster is unable to elect a new primary until a Secondary had completed the operations. Meaning if alter takes 10 hours, we have a possible cluster without Primary for 10 hours. See also bug: https://bugs.mysql.com/bug.php?id=103421

Conclusion

It seems that at the moment we have a partial coverage of the online ddl feature when using group_replication. Of course to have to wait for the SECONDARY nodes is better and less impacting than to wait for PRIMARY first and then the SECONDARIES.

But is confusing given I was expecting to have either full online coverage (I had explicitly asked for that in the DDL command), or a message telling me it cannot be executed online. 

Of course I would prefer to have FULL online coverage ;0) 

Keep in mind my setup was also pretty standard and that changing group_replication_consistency does not affect the outcome. But not sure I can classify this as a bug, more an unexpected undesirable behavior.

Finally I cannot avoid to say that it seems to me a bit too much expect to have the users accepting to wait for two times the time of an alter, first on the primary then on the secondary nodes. I know we have PT-OSC to save the day, but I really think that native support should be better and allow the alter to start when it starts on the Primary, not after doubling the required time.

This blog provides high availability (HA) guidelines using group replication architecture and deployment recommendations in MySQL, based on our best practices.

Every architecture and deployment depends on the customer requirements and application demands for high availability and the estimated level of usage. For example, using high read or high write applications, or both, with a need for 99.999% availability.

Here, we give architecture and deployment recommendations along with a technical overview for a solution that provides a high level of high availability and assumes the usage of high read/write applications (20k or more queries per second).

Layout

Components

This architecture is composed of two main layers:

• Connection and distribution layer
• RDBMS (Relational Database Management System) layer

Connection Layer

The connection layer is composed of:

• Application to proxy redirection mechanism which can be anything from a Virtual IP managed by Keepalived local service to a DNS resolution service like Amazon Route 53. Its function is to redirect the traffic to the active Proxy node.
• Proxy connection distribution is composed of two or more nodes. Its role is to redirect the traffic to the active nodes of the Group Replication cluster. In cases like ProxySQL where the proxy is a level 7 proxy and is able to perform Read/Write split, this layer is also in charge of redirecting writes to the Primary node and reads to the Replicas, and of HA to prevent a single point of failure

Data Layer

The data layer is composed of:

• Primary node serving writes (or source) - this is the node that will accept writes and DDL modifications. Data will be processed following the ACID paradigm (atomicity, consistency, isolation, durability) and replicated to all other nodes.
• Replica nodes are the elements serving read requests. Some replica nodes can be elected Primary in case of Primary node failure. A replica node should be able to leave and join back a healthy cluster without impacting the service.
• Replication mechanism to distribute changes across nodes and in this solution is done with Group Replication. Group Replication is a tightly coupled solution which means that the database cluster is based on a Datacentric approach (single state of the data, distributed commit). In this case, the data is consistent in time across nodes and replication requires a high performant link. Given that, geographic distribution is strongly discouraged and Disaster Recovery (DR) is not implicitly supported by the main Group Replication mechanism. 

The node characteristics (CPU/RAM/Storage) are not relevant to the main solution design.  They instead must reflect the estimated workload the solution will have to cover, which is a case-by-case identification. 

What is important to keep in mind is that all nodes that are part of the cluster must have the same characteristics.  If they don’t, the cluster will be imbalanced and service will be affected.

As a generic indication, we recommend using solutions with at least 8 cores and 16GB RAM when production.  

High Availability

How do we measure availability and at what point does it become “high” availability?

Generally speaking, the measurement of availability is done by establishing a measurement time frame and dividing it by the time that it was available. This ratio will rarely be 1, which is equal to 100% availability. At Percona we don’t consider a solution to be highly available if it is not at least 99% or “two nines” available.  

How is High Availability Achieved?

There are three key components to high availability:

1. Infrastructure - This is the physical or virtual hardware that database systems rely on to run. Without enough infrastructure (VM’s, networking, etc) there cannot be high availability. The easiest example is: there is no way to make a single server highly available.
2. Topology Management - This is the software management related specifically to the database and managing its ability to stay consistent in the event of a failure. Many clustering or synchronous replication solutions offer this capability out of the box. However, for asynchronous replication, this is handled by additional software. 
3. Connection Management - This is the software management related specifically to the networking and connectivity aspect of the database. Clustering solutions typically bundle with a connection manager, however in asynchronous clusters deploying a connection manager is mandatory for high availability.

This Solution Provides:

The proposed solution, based on a tightly coupled database cluster, offers an HA level of 99.995% when coupled with the Group replication setting group_replication_consistency=AFTER.

Failovers

If properly planned and architected, a database failure or configuration change that requires a restart shouldn’t affect the stability of the database infrastructure. Failovers are an integral part of a stability strategy and aligning the business requirements for availability and uptime with failover methodologies is critical to achieving those goals. Below are the 3 main types of failovers that can occur in database environments.

• Planned Failover: A planned failover is a failover that has been scheduled in advance or occurs at a regular interval. There can be many reasons for planned failovers including patching, large data operations, retiring existing infrastructure, or simply testing the failover strategy.
• Unplanned Failover: An unplanned failover is what occurs when a database unexpectedly becomes unresponsive or experiences instability. This could also include emergency changes that do not fall under the planned failover cadence or scheduling parameters. Unplanned failovers are generally considered higher-risk operations due to the high stress and high potential for either data corruption or data fragmentation.
• Regional or Disaster Recovery Failover: Unplanned failovers still work with the assumption that additional database infrastructure is immediately available and in a usable state. In a regional or DR failover, we would be making the assumption that there is a large-scale infrastructure outage that requires the business to move its operations away from its current availability zone.
• This solution covers both planned and unplanned failovers.

Maintenance Windows

Major vs Minor Maintenance: Although it may not be obvious at first, not all maintenance activities are created equal and do not have the same dependencies. It is good to separate maintenance that demands downtime or failover from maintenance that can be done without impacting those important stability metrics. When defining these maintenance dependencies there can be a change in the actual maintenance process that allows for a different cadence.

Maintenance Without Service Interruption: With rolling restart and using proper version upgrade it is possible to cover both major and minor maintenance without service interruption.

Uptime

When referring to database stability, uptime is likely the largest indicator of stability and oftentimes is the most obvious symptom of an unstable database environment. Uptime is composed of 3 key components and, contrary to common perception, is based on what happens when the database software is not able to take incoming requests rather than maintaining the ability to take requests with errors.

Recovery Time Objective (RTO): This can be boiled down to a very simple question “How long can the business sustain a database outage?”. Once the business is aligned with a goal of a minimum viable recovery time objective, it is much more straightforward to plan and invest in the infrastructure required to meet that requirement. It is important to acknowledge that while everyone desires 100% uptime, there is a need for realistic expectations that align with the business needs and not a technical desire.

Recovery Point Objective (RPO): There is a big distinction between the Recovery Point and the Recovery Time for database infrastructure. The database can be available, but not to the exact state that it was when it became unavailable. That is where Recovery Point comes in. The question we ask here is “How much data can the business lose during a database outage?”. All businesses have their own requirements here and it is worthy to note that it is always the goal to never sustain any data loss. But this is framed in a worst-case scenario how much data could be lost and the business maintains the ability to continue.

Disaster Recovery: While RTO and RPO are great for unplanned outages or small-scale hiccups to the infrastructure, when we talk about Disaster Recovery this is a major large-scale outage not strictly for the database infrastructure. How capable is the business of restarting operations with the assumption that all resources are completely unavailable in the main availability zone? The assumption here is that there is no viable restoration point or time that aligns with the business requirements. While each DR scenario is unique based on available infrastructure, backup strategy, and technology stack, there are some common threads for any scenario. 

This solution helps improve uptime:

Using this solution will help you to significantly reduce both RPO and RTO. Given the tightly coupled cluster solution approach, the failure of a single node will not result in service interruption.
Increasing the number of nodes will also improve the cluster resilience by the formula:
F = (N -1) / 2

Where:

F - Number of admissible failures

N - number of nodes in the cluster

Examples:

In a cluster of 5 nodes, F = (5 - 1)/2 = 2. 

The cluster can support up to 2 failures. 

In a cluster of 4 nodes, F = (4 - 1)/2 = 1.  

The cluster can support up to 1 failure. 

This solution also allows for a more restrictive backup policy, dedicating a node to the backup cycle, which will help in keeping RPO low. As previously mentioned, DR is not covered by default by the solution which will require an additional replication setup and controller. 

Measurement and Monitoring

To ensure database infrastructure is performing as intended or at its best, it is necessary to measure specific metrics and alert when some of these metrics are not in line with expectations. Periodic review of these measurements is also encouraged to promote stability and understand potential risks associated with the database infrastructure. Below are the 3 aspects of Database performance measurement and monitoring

Measurement: To understand how a database infrastructure is performing there is a need to measure multiple aspects of the infrastructure. With measurement, it’s important to understand the impact of the sample sizes, sample timing, and sample types.

Metrics: Metrics refer to the actual parts of the database infrastructure being measured. When we discuss metrics, more isn’t always better as it could introduce unintentional noise or allow for troubleshooting to become overly burdensome.

Alerting: When one or many metrics of the database infrastructure is not within a normal or acceptable range, an alert should be generated so that the team responsible for the appropriate portion of the database infrastructure can investigate and remedy it

Monitoring for this solution is covered by:

Percona Monitoring and Management has a specific dashboard to monitor the Group Replication state and cluster status as a whole. (https://www.percona.com/doc/percona-monitoring-and-management/2.x/introduction.html) has a specific dashboard to monitor Group Replication state, and cluster status as a whole. 

How to Implement the Infrastructure

In this section, we are providing the step by step instructions on how to implement the above solution. 

The Elements

The following will be used:

• 1 Virtual IP for ProxySQL failover - 192.168.4.194
• 2 ProxySQL nodes
  • Proxy1 192.168.4.191
  • Proxy2 192.168.4.192
• 4 MySQL nodes in Single Primary mode
  • Gr1 192.168.4.81 - Initial Primary
  • Gr2 192.168.4.82 - Replica / failover
  • Gr3 192.168.4.83 - Replica / failover
  • Gr4 192.168.4.84 - Replica / Backup
• Ports. All ports must be open if a firewall is in place or any other restriction like AppArmor or SELinux. 
  • Proxysql
    • 6033
    • 6032
    • 3306
  • MySQL - GR
    • 3306
    • 33060
    • 33061

Software Installation

First, you need to install the Percona Distribution for MySQL, the Percona Server for MySQL-based variant, on each node. Follow the instructions at https://www.percona.com/doc/percona-distribution-mysql/8.0/installing.html to install Percona Server for MySQL v8.0.

Configure the Nodes

Before anything, make sure that all the nodes use the same time-zone and time:

    [root@gr1 ps8]# date
    Tue Aug 18 08:22:12 EDT 2020

Check also for ntpd service to be present and enabled. Be sure that each node resolves the other nodes by name:

root@gr1 ps8]# for i in 1 2 3 4 ; do ping -c 1 gr$i > /dev/null;echo $?; done

If not able to resolve, add the entries in the /etc/hosts file.

Once instances are up and running check the Percona Server for MySQL version on each node:

(root@node1) [(none)]>\s
--------------
/opt/mysql_templates/PS-8P/bin/mysql  Ver 8.0.20-11 for Linux on x86_64 (Percona Server (GPL), Release 11, Revision 159f0eb)

Step 1

Create a proper user for administration:

CREATE user dba@localhost identified by 'dbapw';
CREATE user dba@'192.168.%' identified by 'dbapw'; 

GRANT ALL on *.* to dba@localhost with grant option;
GRANT ALL on *.* to dba@'192.168.%' with grant option;

Exit from the client as user root and login as user dba.

Be sure to have a good and unique SERVER_ID value:

(dba@node1) [(none)]>show global variables like 'server_id';
+---------------+-------+
| Variable_name | Value |
+---------------+-------+
| server_id     |     1 | <--- Not good given the same for all nodes
+---------------+-------+
1 row in set (0.01 sec)

It's now time to add group replication settings to the instances.

Step 2

Stop all running nodes, then in the my.cnf add:

 #####################
    #Replication + binlog settings
    #####################
    auto-increment-increment                                    =1
    auto-increment-offset                                       =1

    log-bin                                             =<path_to_logs>/binlog
    log-bin-index                                       =binlog.index
    binlog-checksum                                             =NONE
    binlog-format                                               =ROW
    binlog-row-image                                            =FULL
    log-slave-updates 						=1
    binlog-transaction-dependency-tracking                      =WRITESET_SESSION


    enforce-gtid-consistency                                    =TRUE
    gtid-mode                                                   =ON

    master-info-file                                            =master.info
    master-info-repository                                      =TABLE
    relay_log_info_repository                                   =TABLE
    relay-log                                            =<path_to_logs>/relay

    sync-binlog                                                 =1

    ### SLAVE SECTION
    skip-slave-start
    slave-parallel-type                                        = LOGICAL_CLOCK
    slave-parallel-workers                                      = 4
    slave-preserve-commit-order                                 = 1

    ######################################
    #Group Replication
    ######################################
    plugin_load_add                                    ='group_replication.so'
    plugin-load-add                                    ='mysql_clone.so'
    group_replication_group_name       ="aaaaaaaa-aaaa-aaaa-aaaa-aaaaaaaaaaaa" <-- Not good use something that will help you 
                                                                            to identify the GR transactions and from where they 
                                                                             come from IE "dc1euz1-aaaa-aaaa-aaaa-aaaaaaaaaaaa"
    group_replication_start_on_boot                     =off
    group_replication_local_address                     = "192.168.4.81/2/3/4:33061"  <---- CHANGE THIS TO MATCH EACH NODE LOCAL IP
    group_replication_group_seeds                       = "192.168.4.81:33061,192.168.4.82:33061,192.168.4.83:33061,192.168.4.84:33061"
    group_replication_bootstrap_group                   = off
    transaction-write-set-extraction                    = XXHASH64

Restart all nodes and connect to them.

Step 3

Create a user for replication (on all nodes):

   SET SQL_LOG_BIN=0;
    CREATE USER replica@'192.168.4.%' IDENTIFIED BY 'replicapw';   #<--- Please note the filter by IP is more restrictive 
    GRANT REPLICATION SLAVE ON *.* TO replica@'192.168.4.%';
    FLUSH PRIVILEGES;
    SET SQL_LOG_BIN=1;

Link the nodes with replication channel (on all nodes):

CHANGE MASTER TO MASTER_USER='replica', MASTER_PASSWORD='replicapw' FOR CHANNEL 'group_replication_recovery';

Check the current status:

(dba@node1) [(none)]>\u performance_schema
    (dba@node1) [performance_schema]>show tables like '%repl%';
    +-------------------------------------------+
    | Tables_in_performance_schema (%repl%)     |
    +-------------------------------------------+
    | replication_applier_configuration         |
    | replication_applier_filters               |
    | replication_applier_global_filters        |
    | replication_applier_status                |
    | replication_applier_status_by_coordinator |
    | replication_applier_status_by_worker      |
    | replication_connection_configuration      |
    | replication_connection_status             |
    | replication_group_member_stats            |
    | replication_group_members                 | <------------------------
    +-------------------------------------------+

   (dba@node1) [performance_schema]>select * from replication_group_members\G
CHANNEL_NAME: group_replication_applier
     MEMBER_ID: 
   MEMBER_HOST: 
   MEMBER_PORT: 
  MEMBER_STATE: 
   MEMBER_ROLE: OFFLINE
MEMBER_VERSION: 
1 row in set (0.00 sec)

At this stage, you should be able to start the first (Primary) cluster node.

Only on GR1:

(dba@node1)[none]> SET GLOBAL group_replication_bootstrap_group=ON;
(dba@node1)[none]> START GROUP_REPLICATION;
(dba@node1)[none]> SET GLOBAL group_replication_bootstrap_group=OFF;

And then check it:

(dba@node1) [none]>select * from performance_schema.replication_group_members\G
     CHANNEL_NAME: group_replication_applier
     MEMBER_ID: 90a353b8-e6dc-11ea-98fa-08002734ed50
   MEMBER_HOST: gr1
   MEMBER_PORT: 3306
  MEMBER_STATE: ONLINE
   MEMBER_ROLE: PRIMARY
MEMBER_VERSION: 8.0.20

Once the Primary is running, connect on the second node GR2 and start Group replication:

(dba@node2) [none]>START GROUP_REPLICATION;
Query OK, 0 rows affected (4.60 sec)

Check if it registered correctly:

    (dba@node2) [performance_schema]>select * from replication_group_members\G
*************************** 1. row ***************************
  CHANNEL_NAME: group_replication_applier
     MEMBER_ID: 58ffd118-e6dc-11ea-8af8-08002734ed50
   MEMBER_HOST: gr2
   MEMBER_PORT: 3306
  MEMBER_STATE: ONLINE
   MEMBER_ROLE: SECONDARY
MEMBER_VERSION: 8.0.20
*************************** 2. row ***************************
  CHANNEL_NAME: group_replication_applier
     MEMBER_ID: 90a353b8-e6dc-11ea-98fa-08002734ed50
   MEMBER_HOST: gr1
   MEMBER_PORT: 3306
  MEMBER_STATE: ONLINE
   MEMBER_ROLE: PRIMARY
MEMBER_VERSION: 8.0.20

Test if replication works:

On GR1

(dba@node1) [performance_schema]>create schema test;
Query OK, 1 row affected (0.76 sec)

(dba@node1) [performance_schema]>\u test
Database changed

(dba@node1) [test]>create table test1 (`id` int auto_increment primary key);
Query OK, 0 rows affected (0.32 sec)

(dba@node1) [test]>insert into test1 values(null);
Query OK, 1 row affected (0.34 sec)

On GR2

 (dba@node2) [performance_schema]>use \test
 Database changed
 (dba@node2) [test]>select * from test1;
 +----+
 | id |
 +----+
 |  1 |
 +----+
 1 row in set (0.00 sec)

Start group replication of the other two nodes GR3 and GR4:

(dba@node3) [performance_schema]>START GROUP_REPLICATION;
(dba@node4) [performance_schema]>START GROUP_REPLICATION;

Proxy Setup

Step 1

In our solution we will use two ProxySQL nodes:

• Proxy1 192.168.4.191
• Proxy2 192.168.4.192

First, you need to install ProxySQL on the nodes you have selected, in our case the two above.

To install the software follow the instructions in How to Install ProxySQL From the Percona Repository. Once you have installed the software, we first need to grant access to the ProxySQL monitor user to our Percona Server for MySQL nodes.

Create monitor user in MySQL group replication nodes:

Create monitor user in MySQL group replication nodes:
create user monitor@'192.168.4.%' identified by 'monitor';
grant usage on *.* to 'monitor'@'192.168.4.%';
grant select on sys.* to 'monitor'@'192.168.4.%';

Then define some basic variables:

update global_variables set Variable_Value='admin:admin;cluster1:clusterpass'  where Variable_name='admin-admin_credentials';
update global_variables set variable_value='cluster1' where variable_name='admin-cluster_username';
update global_variables set variable_value='clusterpass' where variable_name='admin-cluster_password';
update global_variables set Variable_Value=0  where Variable_name='mysql-hostgroup_manager_verbose';
update global_variables set Variable_Value='true'  where Variable_name='mysql-query_digests_normalize_digest_text';
update global_variables set Variable_Value='8.0.20'  where Variable_name='mysql-server_version';
update global_variables set Variable_Value='utf8'  where Variable_name='mysql-default_charset';
update global_variables set Variable_Value=300  where Variable_name='mysql-tcp_keepalive_time';
update global_variables set Variable_Value='true'  where Variable_name='mysql-use_tcp_keepalive';
update global_variables set Variable_Value='true'  where Variable_name='mysql-verbose_query_error';
update global_variables set Variable_Value='true'  where Variable_name='mysql-show_processlist_extended';
update global_variables set Variable_Value=50000  where Variable_name='mysql-max_stmts_cache';
update global_variables set Variable_Value='false'  where Variable_name='admin-web_enabled';
update global_variables set Variable_Value='0'  where Variable_name='mysql-set_query_lock_on_hostgroup';

load admin variables to run;save admin variables to disk;
load mysql variables to run;save mysql variables to disk;

The user name and password need to reflect your standards. The ones used above are just an example. Then set up the nodes as a cluster:

INSERT INTO proxysql_servers (hostname,port,weight,comment) VALUES('192.168.4.191',6032,100,'PRIMARY');
INSERT INTO proxysql_servers (hostname,port,weight,comment) VALUES('192.168.4.192',6032,100,'SECONDARY');
load proxysql servers to run;save proxysql servers to disk;

Step 2

Define user(s), servers, and query rules to perform read/write split. Create one or more valid user(s), for instance, if you have a user named app_gr with the password test, that has access to your group replication cluster:

insert into mysql_users (username,password,active,default_hostgroup,default_schema,transaction_persistent,comment) values ('app_gr','test',1,400,'mysql',1,'application test user GR');
LOAD MYSQL USERS TO RUNTIME;SAVE MYSQL USERS TO DISK;

Define servers:

INSERT INTO mysql_servers (hostname,hostgroup_id,port,weight,max_connections,comment) VALUES ('192.168.4.81',400,3306,10000,2000,'GR1');
INSERT INTO mysql_servers (hostname,hostgroup_id,port,weight,max_connections,comment) VALUES ('192.168.4.81',401,3306,100,2000,'GR1');
INSERT INTO mysql_servers (hostname,hostgroup_id,port,weight,max_connections,comment) VALUES ('192.168.4.82',401,3306,10000,2000,'GR2');    
INSERT INTO mysql_servers (hostname,hostgroup_id,port,weight,max_connections,comment) VALUES ('192.168.4.83',401,3306,10000,2000,'GR2');        
INSERT INTO mysql_servers (hostname,hostgroup_id,port,weight,max_connections,comment) VALUES ('192.168.4.84',401,3306,1,2000,'GR2');        
LOAD MYSQL SERVERS TO RUNTIME; SAVE MYSQL SERVERS TO DISK;

Define query rules to get read-write split:

INSERT INTO mysql_query_rules (rule_id,proxy_port,username,destination_hostgroup,active,retries,match_digest,apply) values(4040,6033,'app_gr',400,1,3,'^SELECT.*FOR UPDATE',1);
INSERT INTO mysql_query_rules (rule_id,proxy_port,username,destination_hostgroup,active,retries,match_digest,multiplex,apply) values(4042,6033,'app_gr',401,1,3,'^SELECT.*$',1,1);
LOAD MYSQL QUERY RULES TO RUN;SAVE MYSQL QUERY RULES TO DISK;

Step 3

Once we have all the configuration ready, we need to have a special view in the SYS schema in our Percona server nodes. The view working for the server version 8 and above can be found here (https://github.com/Percona-Lab/group_replication_tools/blob/master/GR_sys_view_forProxysql_v1.sql) 

Run that sql on the PRIMARY node of the Group Replication cluster.

Step 4

Now we are ready to activate the native support for Group Replication in ProxySQL. We will use the following group definition:

Writer HG-> 400
Reader HG-> 401
BackupW HG-> 402
Offline HG-> 9401 

INSERT INTO mysql_group_replication_hostgroups (writer_hostgroup,backup_writer_hostgroup,reader_hostgroup, offline_hostgroup,active,max_writers,writer_is_also_reader,max_transactions_behind) 
values (400,402,401,9401,1,1,1,100);
LOAD MYSQL SERVERS TO RUNTIME; SAVE MYSQL SERVERS TO DISK;

Few comments here about the parameters (for full reference see here https://proxysql.com/documentation/main-runtime#mysql_group_replication_hostgroups ). We recommend setting the number of writers always to 1, and witer_is_also_reader to 1 as well to obtain the most reliable results.

max_writers: 1
writer_is_also_reader: 1

The max_transactions_behind is a subjective parameter that you should calculate on the basis of your needs. If for instance you cannot have a stale read, it will be safe to set this value to a low number (ie 50) and to set in all Group replication nodes:

set global group_replication_consistency=AFTER;

If instead, you have no issue or strict requirements about some stale read, you can relax the parameter and ignore the group_replication_consistency setting. Our recommended setting is group_replication_consistency=AFTER and max_transactions_behind: 100.

Proxy HA

The final step is to enable High Availability for the ProxySQL layer. In this approach, we will use the well-known keepalived service. First, install the keepalived software using yum or apt-get on each ProxySQL node:

Sudo yum install -y keepalived
Or
Sudo apt-get install -y keepalived

Then modify the /etc/keepalived/keepalived.conf file accordingly to your setup. In our case:

• Proxy1 192.168.4.0/24 dev enp0s9 proto kernel scope link src 192.168.4.191
• Proxy2 192.168.4.0/24 dev enp0s9 proto kernel scope link src 192.168.4.192
• VIP       192.168.4.194

We want to have the primary to be Proxy1 and the failover node to be Proxy2. Given that the config will look like:

cat /etc/keepalived/keepalived.conf 
global_defs {
  # Keepalived process identifier
  router_id  proxy_HA
}
# Script used to check if Proxy is running
vrrp_script check_proxy {
  script "killall -0 proxysql"
  interval 2
  weight 2
}
# Virtual interface
# The priority specifies the order in which the assigned interface to take over in a failover
vrrp_instance VI_01 {
  state MASTER 
  interface enp0s9
  virtual_router_id 51
  priority 100  <----- This needs to be different for each ProxySQL node, like 100/99 
 
  # The virtual ip address shared between the two load balancers
  virtual_ipaddress {
   192.168.4.194  dev enp0s9
  }
  track_script {
    check_proxy
  }
}

Once done, start the keepalived service, and from now on the VIP will be associated with the Proxy1 unless service is down.

In the system log:

proxysql1 Keepalived_vrrp[17422]: VRRP sockpool: [ifindex(4), proto(112), unicast(0), fd(10,11)]
proxysql1 Keepalived_vrrp[17422]: VRRP_Script(check_proxy) succeeded
proxysql1 Keepalived_vrrp[17422]: VRRP_Instance(VI_01) Transition to MASTER STATE
proxysql1 Keepalived_vrrp[17422]: VRRP_Instance(VI_01) Received advert with higher priority 101, ours 100
proxysql1 Keepalived_vrrp[17422]: VRRP_Instance(VI_01) Entering BACKUP STATE
proxysql1 Keepalived_vrrp[17422]: VRRP_Instance(VI_01) Changing effective priority from 100 to 102
proxysql1 Keepalived_vrrp[17422]: VRRP_Instance(VI_01) forcing a new MASTER election
proxysql1 Keepalived_vrrp[17422]: VRRP_Instance(VI_01) Transition to MASTER STATE
proxysql1 Keepalived_vrrp[17422]: VRRP_Instance(VI_01) Entering MASTER STATE
proxysql1 Keepalived_vrrp[17422]: VRRP_Instance(VI_01) setting protocol VIPs.
proxysql1 Keepalived_vrrp[17422]: Sending gratuitous ARP on enp0s9 for 192.168.4.194
proxysql1 Keepalived_vrrp[17422]: VRRP_Instance(VI_01) Sending/queueing gratuitous RPs on enp0s9 for 192.168.4.194
proxysql1 Keepalived_vrrp[17422]: Sending gratuitous ARP on enp0s9 for 192.168.4.194
..
proxysql1 Keepalived_vrrp[17422]: Sending gratuitous ARP on enp0s9 for 192.168.4.194
proxysql1 avahi-daemon[989]: Registering new address record for 192.168.4.194 on enp0s9.IPv4.

Disaster Recovery Implementation

The implementation of a DR (Disaster Recovery) site will follow the same direction provided for the main site. There are only some generic rules that should be followed:

• A DR site should be located in a different geographic location than the main site (several hundred kilometers/miles away).
• The connection link between the main site and the DR site can only be established using asynchronous replication (standard MySQL replication setup ).

Monitoring

There are few ways to monitor a Group Replication cluster. The easiest way is to have Percona Monitoring and Management (Version 2.10 or later) deployed to do it for you. For an easy installation of Percona Monitoring and Management check out this quickstart.

Percona Monitoring and Management

The only important thing to remember is that when registering the Percona Server for MySQL node or the MySQL node, you should specify the replication_set flag.

Ie:  pmm-admin add mysql --username=pmm --password=pmm --query-source=perfschema --replication-set=gr_test_lab  group_rep4 127.0.0.1:3306

Then you can use the Group replication Dashboard and monitor your cluster with a lot of details.

The sections are:

• Overview(3 panels)

• Replication Delay Details(3 panels)

• Transactions(8 panels)

• Conflicts

From Command Line

From the command line you need to manually query the tables in Performance schema:

+----------------------------------------------+
| replication_applier_configuration            |
| replication_applier_filters                  |
| replication_applier_global_filters           |
| replication_applier_status                   |
| replication_applier_status_by_coordinator    |
| replication_applier_status_by_worker         |
| replication_connection_configuration         |
| replication_connection_status                |
| replication_group_member_stats               |
| replication_group_members                    |
+----------------------------------------------+

For instance, to get the lag in the number of transactions on a node:

select @last_exec:=SUBSTRING_INDEX(SUBSTRING_INDEX( @@global.GTID_EXECUTED,':',-1),'-',-1) last_executed;select  @last_rec:=SUBSTRING_INDEX(SUBSTRING_INDEX(Received_transaction_set,':',-1),'-',-1) last_received FROM performance_schema.replication_connection_status WHERE Channel_name = 'group_replication_applier'; select (@last_rec - @last_exec) as real_lag;
+---------------+
| last_executed |
+---------------+
| 125624        |
+---------------+
1 row in set, 1 warning (0.03 sec)

+---------------+
| last_received |
+---------------+
| 125624        |
+---------------+
1 row in set, 1 warning (0.00 sec)

+----------+
| real_lag |
+----------+
|        0 |
+----------+
1 row in set (0.00 sec)

Or use a more composite query:

SELECT
  conn_status.channel_name as channel_name,
  conn_status.service_state as IO_thread,
  applier_status.service_state as SQL_thread,
  conn_status.LAST_QUEUED_TRANSACTION as last_queued_transaction,
  applier_status.LAST_APPLIED_TRANSACTION as last_applied_transaction,
  LAST_APPLIED_TRANSACTION_END_APPLY_TIMESTAMP - 
                            LAST_APPLIED_TRANSACTION_ORIGINAL_COMMIT_TIMESTAMP 'rep delay (sec)',
  LAST_QUEUED_TRANSACTION_START_QUEUE_TIMESTAMP - 
                           LAST_QUEUED_TRANSACTION_ORIGINAL_COMMIT_TIMESTAMP 'transport time', 
  LAST_QUEUED_TRANSACTION_END_QUEUE_TIMESTAMP - 
                           LAST_QUEUED_TRANSACTION_START_QUEUE_TIMESTAMP 'time RL',
  LAST_APPLIED_TRANSACTION_END_APPLY_TIMESTAMP - 
                           LAST_APPLIED_TRANSACTION_START_APPLY_TIMESTAMP 'apply time',  
  if(GTID_SUBTRACT(LAST_QUEUED_TRANSACTION, LAST_APPLIED_TRANSACTION) = "","0" ,        abs(time_to_sec(if(time_to_sec(APPLYING_TRANSACTION_ORIGINAL_COMMIT_TIMESTAMP)=0,0,timediff(APPLYING_TRANSACTION_ORIGINAL_COMMIT_TIMESTAMP,now()))))) `lag_in_sec` 
FROM
  performance_schema.replication_connection_status AS conn_status
JOIN performance_schema.replication_applier_status_by_worker AS applier_status
  ON applier_status.channel_name = conn_status.channel_name
ORDER BY lag_in_sec, lag_in_sec desc\G

Which will provide information about each applier:

*************************** 1. row ***************************
channel_name: group_replication_applier
IO_thread: ON
SQL_thread: ON
last_queued_transaction: aaaaaaaa-aaaa-aaaa-aaaa-aaaaaaaaaaaa:125624
last_applied_transaction: aaaaaaaa-aaaa-aaaa-aaaa-aaaaaaaaaaaa:125621
rep delay (sec): 3.153038
transport time: 0.061327
time RL: 0.001005
apply time: 0.388680
lag_in_sec: 0

As you can see, Percona Monitoring and Management will give you a better view without compromising the details. 

Conclusions

Using these steps and recommendations, you can set up database infrastructure with high availability based on group replication and use Percona Monitoring and Managemen to monitor the infrastructure’s performance and health. 

Keep in mind that we are constantly working on making our recommendations better. As such, what is illustrated here is subject to changes and revision especially on the basis of the increasing adoption of Group Replication. This is because the more GR is used the more edge cases or deviation we will identify. Those are a significant help for us to refine our best practices.

Where x is >= 22 ;)

The Problem

There are few things your data does not like. One is water and another is fire. Well, guess what:

If you think that everything will be fine after all, take a look:

Given my ISP had part of its management infrastructure on OVH, they had been impacted by the incident.

As you can see from the highlight, the ticket number in three years changes very little (2k cases) and the date jumps from 2018 to 2021. On top of that, I have to mention I had opened several tickets the month before that disappeared. 

So either my ISP was very lucky and had very few cases in three years and sent all my tickets to /dev/null... or they have lost THREE YEARS of data.   

Let us go straight to the chase; they have lost their data, period. 

After the fire at the OVH, these guys did not have a good backup to use for data restoring and did not even have a decent Disaster Recovery solution. Their platform remained INACCESSIBLE for more than five days, during which they also lost visibility of their own network/access point/clients and so on.   

Restoring data has brought them back online, but it takes them more than a month to review and fix the internal management system and bring the service back to acceptable standards. Needless to say, complaints and more costly legal actions had been raised against them.

All this because they missed two basic Best Practices when designing a system:

• Good backup/restore procedure
• Always have a Disaster Recovery solution in place 

Yeah, I know... I should change ISP. 

Anyhow, a Disaster Recovery (DR) solution is a crucial element in any production system. It is weird we still have to cover this in 2021, but apparently, it still is something being underestimated that requires our attention. 

This is why in this (long) article, I will illustrate how to implement another improved DR solution utilizing Percona Server for MySQL and standard MySQL features as group replication and asynchronous replication automatic failover (AAF).

Asynchronous Replication Automatic Failover

I have already covered the new MySQL feature here (http://www.tusacentral.net/joomla/index.php/mysql-blogs/227-mysql-asynchronous-source-auto-failover) but let us recap.

From MySQL 8.0.22 and Percona Server for MySQL 8.0.22 you can take advantage of AAF when designing distributed solutions. What does this mean?

When using simple Async-replication you have this:

Whereas, a Highly Available (HA) solution in DC2 is pulling data out from another HA solution in DC1 with the relation 1:1, meaning the connection is one node against another node.

If you have this:

Your data replication is interrupted and the two DCs diverge. Also you need to manually (or by script) recover the interrupted link. With AAF you can count on a significant improvement:

The link now is NOT 1:1, but a node in DC2 can count on AAF to recover the link on the other remaining nodes:

If a node in the DC2 (the replica side) fails, then the link is broken again and it requires manual intervention. This solves a quite large chunk of problems, but it does not fix all, as I mentioned in the article above.

If a node in the DC2 (the replica side) fails, then the link is broken again and it requires manual intervention.

GR Failover

I was hoping to have this fixed in MySQL 8.0.23, but unfortunately, it is not. So I decided to develop a Proof Of Concept and see if it would fix the problem, and more importantly what needs to be done to do it safely. 

The result is a very basic (and I need to refine the code) Stored Procedure called grfailover, which manages the shift between primaries inside a Group Replication cluster:

I borrowed the concept from Yves' Replication Manager for Percona XtraDB Cluster (https://github.com/y-trudeau/Mysql-tools/tree/master/PXC), but as we will see for GR and this use we need much less.

Why Can This Be a Simplified Version?

Because in GR we already have a lot of information and we also have the autofailover for async replication. Given that, what we need to do is only manage the start/stop of the Replica. Auto-failover will take care of the shift from one source to the other, while GR will take care of which node should be the preferred Replica (Primary on replica site). 

In short, the check just needs to see if the node is a Primary, and if so, start the replication if it is not already active while eventually stopping it if the node IS NOT a primary.

We can also maintain a table of what is going on, to be sure that we do not have two nodes replicating at the same time.

The definition will be something like this:

+--------------+---------------+------+-----+---------+-------+
| Field        | Type          | Null | Key | Default | Extra |
+--------------+---------------+------+-----+---------+-------+
| server_uuid  | char(36)      | NO   | PRI | NULL    |       |
| HOST         | varchar(255)  | NO   |     | NULL    |       |
| PORT         | int           | NO   |     | 3306    |       |
| channel_name | varchar(100)  | NO   |     | NULL    |       |
| gr_role      | varchar(30)   | NO   |     | NULL    |       |
| STATUS       | varchar(50)   | YES  |     | NULL    |       |
| started      | timestamp(6)  | YES  |     | NULL    |       |
| lastupdate   | timestamp(6)  | YES  |     | NULL    |       |
| active       | tinyint       | YES  |     | 0       |       |
| COMMENT      | varchar(2000) | YES  |     | NULL    |       |
+--------------+---------------+------+-----+---------+-------+

The full code can be found in GitHub here: https://github.com/Tusamarco/blogs/tree/master/asyncAutoFailOver.

How-To

The first thing you need to do is deploy Percona Server Distribution for MySQL (8.0.22 or greater) using Group Replication as a HA solution. To do so, refer to the extensive guide here: Percona Distribution for MySQL: High Availability with Group Replication Solution.

Once you have it running on both DCs, you can configure AAF on both DCs Primary node following either MySQL 8.0.22: Asynchronous Replication Automatic Connection (IO Thread) Failover or this MySQL Asynchronous SOURCE auto failover.

Once you have the AAF replication up and running, it is time for you to create the procedure and the management table in your DC-Source Primary.

First of all, be sure you have a `percona` schema, and if not, create it:

Create schema percona;

Then create the table:

CREATE TABLE `group_replication_failover_manager` (
  `server_uuid` char(36) NOT NULL,
  `HOST` varchar(255) NOT NULL,
  `PORT` int NOT NULL DEFAULT '3306',
  `channel_name` varchar(100) NOT NULL,
  `gr_role` varchar(30) NOT NULL,
  `STATUS` varchar(50) DEFAULT NULL,
  `started` timestamp(6) NULL DEFAULT NULL,
  `lastupdate` timestamp(6) NULL DEFAULT NULL,
  `active` tinyint DEFAULT '0',
  `COMMENT` varchar(2000) DEFAULT NULL,
  PRIMARY KEY (`server_uuid`)
) ENGINE=InnoDB;

Last, create the procedure. Keep in mind you may need to change the DEFINER or simply remove it. The code will be replicated on all nodes. To be sure, run the command below on all nodes:

select ROUTINE_SCHEMA,ROUTINE_NAME,ROUTINE_TYPE from information_schema.ROUTINES where ROUTINE_SCHEMA ='percona' ;
+----------------+--------------+--------------+
| ROUTINE_SCHEMA | ROUTINE_NAME | ROUTINE_TYPE |
+----------------+--------------+--------------+
| percona        | grfailover   | PROCEDURE    |
+----------------+--------------+--------------+

You should get something as above. 

If not, then check your replication, something probably needs to be fixed. If instead, it all works out, this means you are ready to go.

To run the procedure you can use any kind of approach you like, the only important thing is that you MUST run it FIRST on the current PRIMARY node of each DCs. 

This is because the PRIMARY node must be the first one to register in the management table. Personally, I like to run it from cron when in “production” while manually when testing:

IE:/opt/mysql_templates/PS-8P/bin/mysql -h 127.0.0.1 -P 3306 -D percona -e "call  grfailover(5,\"dc2_to_dc1\");"

Where:

• grfailover is the name of the procedure.
• 5 is the timeout in minutes after which the procedure will activate the replication in the Node.
• dc2_to_dc1 Is the name of the channel in the current node, the procedure needs to manage.

Given two clusters as:

DC1-1(root@localhost) [(none)]>SELECT * FROM performance_schema.replication_group_members;
+---------------------------+--------------------------------------+-------------+-------------+--------------+-------------+----------------+
| CHANNEL_NAME              | MEMBER_ID                            | MEMBER_HOST | MEMBER_PORT | MEMBER_STATE | MEMBER_ROLE | MEMBER_VERSION |
+---------------------------+--------------------------------------+-------------+-------------+--------------+-------------+----------------+
| group_replication_applier | e891d1b4-9793-11eb-92ac-08002734ed50 | gr3         |        3306 | ONLINE       | SECONDARY   | 8.0.23         |
| group_replication_applier | ebff1ab8-9793-11eb-ba5f-08002734ed50 | gr1         |        3306 | ONLINE       | SECONDARY   | 8.0.23         |
| group_replication_applier | f47df54e-9793-11eb-a60b-08002734ed50 | gr2         |        3306 | ONLINE       | PRIMARY     | 8.0.23         |
+---------------------------+--------------------------------------+-------------+-------------+--------------+-------------+----------------+

DC2-2(root@localhost) [percona]>SELECT * FROM performance_schema.replication_group_members;
+---------------------------+--------------------------------------+-------------+-------------+--------------+-------------+----------------+
| CHANNEL_NAME              | MEMBER_ID                            | MEMBER_HOST | MEMBER_PORT | MEMBER_STATE | MEMBER_ROLE | MEMBER_VERSION |
+---------------------------+--------------------------------------+-------------+-------------+--------------+-------------+----------------+
| group_replication_applier | 79ede65d-9797-11eb-9963-08002734ed50 | gr4         |        3306 | ONLINE       | SECONDARY   | 8.0.23         |
| group_replication_applier | 7e214802-9797-11eb-a0cf-08002734ed50 | gr6         |        3306 | ONLINE       | PRIMARY     | 8.0.23         |
| group_replication_applier | 7fddf04f-9797-11eb-a193-08002734ed50 | gr5         |        3306 | ONLINE       | SECONDARY   | 8.0.23         |
+---------------------------+--------------------------------------+-------------+-------------+--------------+-------------+----------------+

If you query the management table after you have run the procedure ONLY on the two Primaries:

>select * from percona.group_replication_failover_manager order by host\G
*************************** 1. row ***************************
server_uuid: f47df54e-9793-11eb-a60b-08002734ed50
        HOST: gr2
        PORT: 3306
channel_name: dc2_to_dc1
     gr_role: PRIMARY
      STATUS: ONLINE
     started: 2021-04-08 10:22:40.000000
  lastupdate: 2021-04-08 10:22:53.000000
      active: 1
     COMMENT: Just inserted
*************************** 2. row ***************************
 server_uuid: 7e214802-9797-11eb-a0cf-08002734ed50
        HOST: gr6
        PORT: 3306
channel_name: dc1_to_dc2
     gr_role: PRIMARY
      STATUS: ONLINE
     started: 2021-04-08 09:17:50.000000
  lastupdate: 2021-04-08 09:17:50.000000
      active: 1
     COMMENT: Just inserted

Given the replication link was already active, the nodes will report only “Just Inserted” in the comment. 

While if one of the two channels was down and the node NOT deactivated (set the active flag in the management table to 0), the comment will change to “COMMENT: REPLICA restarted for the channel <channel name>”

At this point, you can run the procedure also on the other nodes and after that, if you query the table by channel:

DC1-1(root@localhost) [(none)]>select * from percona.group_replication_failover_manager where channel_name ='dc2_to_dc1' order by host\G
*************************** 1. row ***************************
 server_uuid: ebff1ab8-9793-11eb-ba5f-08002734ed50
        HOST: gr1
        PORT: 3306
channel_name: dc2_to_dc1
     gr_role: SECONDARY
      STATUS: ONLINE
     started: NULL
  lastupdate: NULL
      active: 1
     COMMENT: Just inserted
*************************** 2. row ***************************
 server_uuid: f47df54e-9793-11eb-a60b-08002734ed50
        HOST: gr2
        PORT: 3306
channel_name: dc2_to_dc1
     gr_role: PRIMARY
      STATUS: ONLINE
     started: 2021-04-08 10:22:40.000000
  lastupdate: 2021-04-08 10:22:53.000000
      active: 1
     COMMENT: REPLICA restarted for the channel dc2_to_dc1
*************************** 3. row ***************************
 server_uuid: e891d1b4-9793-11eb-92ac-08002734ed50
        HOST: gr3
        PORT: 3306
channel_name: dc2_to_dc1
     gr_role: SECONDARY
      STATUS: ONLINE
     started: NULL
  lastupdate: NULL
      active: 1
     COMMENT: Just inserted
3 rows in set (0.00 sec)

What happens if I now change my Primary, or if the Primary goes down? Well let say we “just” shift our PRIMARY:

stop slave for channel 'dc2_to_dc1';SELECT group_replication_set_as_primary('ebff1ab8-9793-11eb-ba5f-08002734ed50');
Query OK, 0 rows affected, 1 warning (0.01 sec)

+--------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| group_replication_set_as_primary('ebff1ab8-9793-11eb-ba5f-08002734ed50') |
+--------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| Primary server switched to: ebff1ab8-9793-11eb-ba5f-08002734ed50         |
+--------------------------------------------------------------------------+

Please note that given I have an ACTIVE replication channel, to successfully shift the primary, I MUST stop the replication channel first.

C1-2(root@localhost) [percona]>DC1-2(root@localhost) [percona]>SELECT * FROM performance_schema.replication_group_members;
+---------------------------+--------------------------------------+-------------+-------------+--------------+-------------+----------------+
| CHANNEL_NAME              | MEMBER_ID                            | MEMBER_HOST | MEMBER_PORT | MEMBER_STATE | MEMBER_ROLE | MEMBER_VERSION |
+---------------------------+--------------------------------------+-------------+-------------+--------------+-------------+----------------+
| group_replication_applier | e891d1b4-9793-11eb-92ac-08002734ed50 | gr3         |        3306 | ONLINE       | SECONDARY   | 8.0.23         |
| group_replication_applier | ebff1ab8-9793-11eb-ba5f-08002734ed50 | gr1         |        3306 | ONLINE       | PRIMARY     | 8.0.23         |
| group_replication_applier | f47df54e-9793-11eb-a60b-08002734ed50 | gr2         |        3306 | ONLINE       | SECONDARY   | 8.0.23         |
+---------------------------+--------------------------------------+-------------+-------------+--------------+-------------+----------------+

Reading the management table we will see that grFailOver had started the shift:

DC1-1(root@localhost) [(none)]>select * from percona.group_replication_failover_manager where channel_name ='dc2_to_dc1' order by host\G
*************************** 1. row ***************************
 server_uuid: ebff1ab8-9793-11eb-ba5f-08002734ed50
        HOST: gr1
        PORT: 3306
channel_name: dc2_to_dc1
     gr_role: PRIMARY
      STATUS: ONLINE
     started: NULL
  lastupdate: NULL
      active: 1
     COMMENT: Need to wait 5 minutes, passed: 0
*************************** 2. row ***************************
 server_uuid: f47df54e-9793-11eb-a60b-08002734ed50
        HOST: gr2
        PORT: 3306
channel_name: dc2_to_dc1
     gr_role: PRIMARY
      STATUS: ONLINE
     started: 2021-04-08 10:22:40.000000
  lastupdate: 2021-04-08 10:22:53.000000
      active: 1
     COMMENT: REPLICA restarted for the channel dc2_to_dc1
*************************** 3. row ***************************
 server_uuid: e891d1b4-9793-11eb-92ac-08002734ed50
        HOST: gr3
        PORT: 3306
channel_name: dc2_to_dc1
     gr_role: SECONDARY
      STATUS: ONLINE
     started: NULL
  lastupdate: NULL
      active: 1
     COMMENT: Just inserted

Checking the new PRIMARY node gr1, we can see that:

• Gr_role is PRIMARY
• COMMENT reports the countdown (in minutes) the node waits

After the 5 minutes: 

DC1-1(root@localhost) [(none)]>select * from percona.group_replication_failover_manager where channel_name ='dc2_to_dc1' order by host\G
*************************** 1. row ***************************
 server_uuid: ebff1ab8-9793-11eb-ba5f-08002734ed50
        HOST: gr1
        PORT: 3306
channel_name: dc2_to_dc1
     gr_role: PRIMARY
      STATUS: ONLINE
     started: 2021-04-08 10:27:54.000000
  lastupdate: 2021-04-08 10:30:12.000000
      active: 1
     COMMENT: REPLICA restarted for the channel dc2_to_dc1
*************************** 2. row ***************************
 server_uuid: f47df54e-9793-11eb-a60b-08002734ed50
        HOST: gr2
        PORT: 3306
channel_name: dc2_to_dc1
     gr_role: SECONDARY
      STATUS: ONLINE
     started: NULL
  lastupdate: NULL
      active: 1
     COMMENT: Resetted by primary node ebff1ab8-9793-11eb-ba5f-08002734ed50 at 2021-04-08 10:27:53
*************************** 3. row ***************************
 server_uuid: e891d1b4-9793-11eb-92ac-08002734ed50
        HOST: gr3
        PORT: 3306
channel_name: dc2_to_dc1
     gr_role: SECONDARY
      STATUS: ONLINE
     started: NULL
  lastupdate: NULL
      active: 1
     COMMENT: Just inserted

Now, what we can see is:

• Node gr1 had become active in replicating
  • It reports the time it started the replication 
  • It reports the last time it checked for the replication to be active
• Node gr2 is marked SECONDARY
  • In the comment is also reported the time and when the replication was restarted on the new REPLICA node

If for any reason the replication in the original node gr2 was restarted (like moving back the PRIMARY) while the countdown was still in place, grFailOver will stop any action and reset the gr1 status. 

In short, now my two DCs can rely on AAF for failing over on a different SOURCE and on grFailOver for shifting the Node following GR Primary, or to failover to another node when my Primary crashes.

Conclusion

I am sure Oracle is backing something about this and I am sure we will see it out soon, but in the meantime, I have to say that this simple solution works. It has improved the resiliency of my testing architecture A LOT. 

And while I am still testing it and I am totally confident that the procedure can be written in a more efficient way, I am also sure bugs and errors are around the corner. 

BUT, this was a POC and I am happy with the outcome. This proves it is not so difficult to make better what we have, and also proves that sometimes a small thing can have a HUGE impact. 

It also proves we should not always wait for others to do what is required and that ANYONE can help. 

Finally, as mentioned above, this is a POC solution, but no one prevents you to start from it and make it a production solution, as my colleague Yves did for his Percona XtraDB Cluster Replication Manager. 

Is just on you!  Great MySQL to all. 

References

https://www.datacenterdynamics.com/en/news/fire-destroys-ovhclouds-sbg2-data-center-strasbourg/

http://www.tusacentral.net/joomla/index.php/mysql-blogs/227-mysql-asynchronous-source-auto-failover

https://github.com/y-trudeau/Mysql-tools/tree/master/PXC

https://www.percona.com/blog/2020/10/26/mysql-8-0-22-asynchronous-replication-automatic-connection-io-thread-failover/

From MySQL to Percona or MariaDB ...and back

As we all know MariaDB starts as a fork of MySQL and then slowly diverges until becoming a different product.

Still I often catch at conferences that MariaDB is a drop-in replacement for MySQL (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drop-in_replacement). This for me is a bold statement given drop-in-replacement: “It refers to the ability to replace one hardware (or software) component with another one without any other code or configuration changes being required and resulting in no negative impacts”. Which by inheritance also means I can go backwards. 

In short if MariaDB is a real drop-in replacement, we should be able to replace the MySQL binaries with the ones coming from MariaDB and then roll back without any issue. 

This short article is the result of my notorious disbelieving about any kind of bold marketing statements.

To be clear I am NOT going to compare the functionalities of the different products, I just want to see if I can replace one with the other.

The tests

What and how

For the tests I will use the latest version of:

• MySQL 5.7 
• Percona Server 5.7
• MariaDb 10.3 

And for the newest:

• MySQL 8.0.22 (8.0.23 is out but PS is not yet, so we cannot compare)
• Percona Server 8.0.22
• MariaDB 10.5

I will have a source pointing to a symbolic link named /opt/mysql_templates/magic then I will replace the target of the link pointing to the different binaries. 

What I will do is simple:

1. Point to MySQL
2. Create a new instance
3. Create the world schema and load data (using Innodb)
4. Select count(*) from world.City;
5. SET GLOBAL innodb_fast_shutdown=0;
6. Stop instance
7. Point link to Percona 
8. Start instance
9. Select count(*) from world.City;
10. Drop world 
11. Repeat all steps from #3 and point to MariaDB
12. Once the MariaDB test is done, point to MySQL and repeat.

Will run the same tests for the 5.7/10.3 series and for the 8.0.22/10.5.

The expectation to be drop-in-replacement is to be able to move from MySQL to Percona Server to MariaDB and back to MySQL. Anything diverging will prove we are NOT dealing with drop-in.

Version 5.7/10.3

MySQL

/opt/mysql_templates/magic/bin/mysql  Ver 14.14 Distrib 5.7.33, for linux-glibc2.12 (x86_64) using  EditLine wrapper
Connection id:		4
Server version:		5.7.33-log MySQL Community Server (GPL)
UNIX socket:		/opt/mysql_instances/magic/mysql.sock
Uptime:			4 sec

+----------+
| count(*) |
+----------+
|     4079 |
+----------+
1 row in set (0.01 sec)

/opt/mysql_templates/magic/bin/mysql  Ver 14.14 Distrib 5.7.33, for linux-glibc2.12 (x86_64) using  EditLine wrapper
Connection id:		4
Server version:		5.7.33-log MySQL Community Server (GPL)
UNIX socket:		/opt/mysql_instances/magic/mysql.sock
Uptime:			4 sec

+----------+
| count(*) |
+----------+
|     4079 |
+----------+
1 row in set (0.01 sec)

Shift to Percona:

/opt/mysql_templates/magic/bin/mysql  Ver 14.14 Distrib 5.7.33-36, for Linux (x86_64) using  6.0

Connection id:		8
Server version:		5.7.33-36-log Percona Server (GPL), Release 36, Revision 7e403c5
UNIX socket:		/opt/mysql_instances/magic/mysql.sock
Uptime:			5 min 38 sec

+----------+
| count(*) |
+----------+
|     4079 |
+----------+
1 row in set (0.00 sec)

/opt/mysql_templates/magic/bin/mysql  Ver 14.14 Distrib 5.7.33-36, for Linux (x86_64) using  6.0

Connection id:		8
Server version:		5.7.33-36-log Percona Server (GPL), Release 36, Revision 7e403c5
UNIX socket:		/opt/mysql_instances/magic/mysql.sock
Uptime:			5 min 38 sec

+----------+
| count(*) |
+----------+
|     4079 |
+----------+
1 row in set (0.00 sec)

No errors at all in the log

Let us go backwards to MySQL

(root@localhost) [world]>\s
--------------
/opt/mysql_templates/magic/bin/mysql  Ver 14.14 Distrib 5.7.33, for linux-glibc2.12 (x86_64) using  EditLine wrapper

Connection id:		7
Server version:		5.7.33-log MySQL Community Server (GPL)
UNIX socket:		/opt/mysql_instances/magic/mysql.sock
Uptime:			5 min 33 sec

Database changed
+----------+
| count(*) |
+----------+
|     4079 |
+----------+
1 row in set (0.00 sec)

(root@localhost) [world]>\s
--------------
/opt/mysql_templates/magic/bin/mysql  Ver 14.14 Distrib 5.7.33, for linux-glibc2.12 (x86_64) using  EditLine wrapper

Connection id:		7
Server version:		5.7.33-log MySQL Community Server (GPL)
UNIX socket:		/opt/mysql_instances/magic/mysql.sock
Uptime:			5 min 33 sec

Database changed
+----------+
| count(*) |
+----------+
|     4079 |
+----------+
1 row in set (0.00 sec)

No issue at all 

Let us try to move to MariaDB 10.3:

So at first attempt it failed, and had to modify my.cnf removing GTID config as Performance schema (see reference section about that).

Once done:

2021-03-07 10:59:22 0 [ERROR] Missing system table mysql.roles_mapping; please run mysql_upgrade to create it
2021-03-07 10:59:22 0 [ERROR] Incorrect definition of table mysql.event: expected column 'sql_mode' at position 14 to have type set(...), found type set(...)
2021-03-07 10:59:22 0 [ERROR] mysqld: Event Scheduler: An error occurred when initializing system tables. Disabling the Event Scheduler.

2021-03-07 10:59:22 0 [ERROR] Missing system table mysql.roles_mapping; please run mysql_upgrade to create it
2021-03-07 10:59:22 0 [ERROR] Incorrect definition of table mysql.event: expected column 'sql_mode' at position 14 to have type set(...), found type set(...)
2021-03-07 10:59:22 0 [ERROR] mysqld: Event Scheduler: An error occurred when initializing system tables. Disabling the Event Scheduler.

Working but needing to run innodb_update, once done, I had a lot of errors related to the Performance schema, and still InnoDB issues:

/opt/mysql_templates/magic/bin/mysql  Ver 15.1 Distrib 10.3.28-MariaDB, for Linux (x86_64) using readline 5.1

Connection id:		76
Server:			MariaDB
Server version:		10.3.28-MariaDB-log MariaDB Server
UNIX socket:		/opt/mysql_instances/magic/mysql.sock
Uptime:			1 min 17 sec

(root@localhost) [(none)]>select count(*) from world.City;
+----------+
| count(*) |
+----------+
|     4079 |
+----------+
1 row in set (0.003 sec)

/opt/mysql_templates/magic/bin/mysql  Ver 15.1 Distrib 10.3.28-MariaDB, for Linux (x86_64) using readline 5.1

Connection id:		76
Server:			MariaDB
Server version:		10.3.28-MariaDB-log MariaDB Server
UNIX socket:		/opt/mysql_instances/magic/mysql.sock
Uptime:			1 min 17 sec

(root@localhost) [(none)]>select count(*) from world.City;
+----------+
| count(*) |
+----------+
|     4079 |
+----------+
1 row in set (0.003 sec)

2021-03-07 11:03:37 229 [ERROR] InnoDB: Column last_update in table `mysql`.`innodb_table_stats` is BINARY(4) NOT NULL but should be INT UNSIGNED NOT NULL (flags mismatch).
2021-03-07 11:03:37 229 [ERROR] InnoDB: Fetch of persistent statistics requested for table `mysql`.`gtid_executed` but the required system tables mysql.innodb_table_stats and mysql.innodb_index_stats are not present or have unexpected structure. Using transient stats instead.
2021-03-07 11:03:38 232 [ERROR] Column count of mysql.proc is wrong. Expected 21, found 20. Created with MariaDB 50733, now running 100328. Please use mysql_upgrade to fix this error
2021-03-07 11:03:38 232 [Note] View `sys`.`x$statements_with_errors_or_warnings`: the version is set to 100328, algorithm restored to be MERGE
2021-03-07 11:03:38 233 [ERROR] InnoDB: Column last_update in table `mysql`.`innodb_table_stats` is BINARY(4) NOT NULL but should be INT UNSIGNED NOT NULL (flags mismatch).
2021-03-07 11:03:38 233 [ERROR] InnoDB: Column last_update in table `mysql`.`innodb_table_stats` is BINARY(4) NOT NULL but should be INT UNSIGNED NOT NULL (flags mismatch).
2021-03-07 11:03:38 233 [ERROR] InnoDB: Column last_update in table `mysql`.`innodb_table_stats` is BINARY(4) NOT NULL but should be INT UNSIGNED NOT NULL (flags mismatch).

2021-03-07 11:03:37 229 [ERROR] InnoDB: Column last_update in table `mysql`.`innodb_table_stats` is BINARY(4) NOT NULL but should be INT UNSIGNED NOT NULL (flags mismatch).
2021-03-07 11:03:37 229 [ERROR] InnoDB: Fetch of persistent statistics requested for table `mysql`.`gtid_executed` but the required system tables mysql.innodb_table_stats and mysql.innodb_index_stats are not present or have unexpected structure. Using transient stats instead.
2021-03-07 11:03:38 232 [ERROR] Column count of mysql.proc is wrong. Expected 21, found 20. Created with MariaDB 50733, now running 100328. Please use mysql_upgrade to fix this error
2021-03-07 11:03:38 232 [Note] View `sys`.`x$statements_with_errors_or_warnings`: the version is set to 100328, algorithm restored to be MERGE
2021-03-07 11:03:38 233 [ERROR] InnoDB: Column last_update in table `mysql`.`innodb_table_stats` is BINARY(4) NOT NULL but should be INT UNSIGNED NOT NULL (flags mismatch).
2021-03-07 11:03:38 233 [ERROR] InnoDB: Column last_update in table `mysql`.`innodb_table_stats` is BINARY(4) NOT NULL but should be INT UNSIGNED NOT NULL (flags mismatch).
2021-03-07 11:03:38 233 [ERROR] InnoDB: Column last_update in table `mysql`.`innodb_table_stats` is BINARY(4) NOT NULL but should be INT UNSIGNED NOT NULL (flags mismatch).

Let us go back to MySQL now: 

2021-03-07T16:27:01.517996Z 0 [ERROR] Native table 'performance_schema'.'session_variables' has the wrong structure
2021-03-07T16:27:01.518307Z 0 [ERROR] Incorrect definition of table mysql.db: expected column 'User' at position 2 to have type char(32), found type char(80).
2021-03-07T16:27:01.518428Z 0 [ERROR] mysql.user has no `Event_priv` column at position 28
2021-03-07T16:27:01.518697Z 0 [ERROR] Incorrect definition of table mysql.event: expected column 'sql_mode' at position 14 to have type set(...), found type set(...)
2021-03-07T16:27:01.518829Z 0 [ERROR] Event Scheduler: An error occurred when initializing system tables. Disabling the Event Scheduler.
2021-03-07T16:27:01.520065Z 0 [Note] /opt/mysql_templates/magic/bin/mysqld: ready for connections.
Version: '5.7.33-log'  socket: '/opt/mysql_instances/magic/mysql.sock'  port: 3306  MySQL Community Server (GPL)

2021-03-07T16:27:01.517996Z 0 [ERROR] Native table 'performance_schema'.'session_variables' has the wrong structure
2021-03-07T16:27:01.518307Z 0 [ERROR] Incorrect definition of table mysql.db: expected column 'User' at position 2 to have type char(32), found type char(80).
2021-03-07T16:27:01.518428Z 0 [ERROR] mysql.user has no `Event_priv` column at position 28
2021-03-07T16:27:01.518697Z 0 [ERROR] Incorrect definition of table mysql.event: expected column 'sql_mode' at position 14 to have type set(...), found type set(...)
2021-03-07T16:27:01.518829Z 0 [ERROR] Event Scheduler: An error occurred when initializing system tables. Disabling the Event Scheduler.
2021-03-07T16:27:01.520065Z 0 [Note] /opt/mysql_templates/magic/bin/mysqld: ready for connections.
Version: '5.7.33-log'  socket: '/opt/mysql_instances/magic/mysql.sock'  port: 3306  MySQL Community Server (GPL)

Try to run mysql_upgrade

mysql@gr1 magic]$ /opt/mysql_templates/magic/bin/mysql_upgrade --defaults-file=./my.cnf -uroot --force
mysql_upgrade: Got error: 1524: Plugin '0' is not loaded while connecting to the MySQL server
Upgrade process encountered error and will not continue.

mysql@gr1 magic]$ /opt/mysql_templates/magic/bin/mysql_upgrade --defaults-file=./my.cnf -uroot --force
mysql_upgrade: Got error: 1524: Plugin '0' is not loaded while connecting to the MySQL server
Upgrade process encountered error and will not continue.

Only way to access the data at this point is to use skip-grant-tables. But that is unsustainable and in any case I continue to get errors in the log.  

Summarizing

Once I have an instance built with MySQL 5.7, I can easily shift to Percona Server 5.7, and eventually go back. I can migrate to MariaDB, but this implies configuration changes and must run mysql_update to modify the core system tables.  Finally cannot rollback to MySQL, modifications done by MariaDB are not allowing it.

Version 8/10.5

MySQL

/opt/mysql_templates/magic8/bin/mysql  Ver 8.0.22 for Linux on x86_64 (MySQL Community Server - GPL)

Connection id:		19
Server version:		8.0.22 MySQL Community Server - GPL
UNIX socket:		/opt/mysql_instances/magic8/mysql.sock
Binary data as:		Hexadecimal
Uptime:			22 sec

(root@localhost) [world]>select count(*) from world.City;
+----------+
| count(*) |
+----------+
|     4079 |
+----------+
1 row in set (0.01 sec)

/opt/mysql_templates/magic8/bin/mysql  Ver 8.0.22 for Linux on x86_64 (MySQL Community Server - GPL)

Connection id:		19
Server version:		8.0.22 MySQL Community Server - GPL
UNIX socket:		/opt/mysql_instances/magic8/mysql.sock
Binary data as:		Hexadecimal
Uptime:			22 sec

(root@localhost) [world]>select count(*) from world.City;
+----------+
| count(*) |
+----------+
|     4079 |
+----------+
1 row in set (0.01 sec)

Move to Percona Server 

/opt/mysql_templates/magic8/bin/mysql  Ver 8.0.22-13 for Linux on x86_64 (Percona Server (GPL), Release 13, Revision 6f7822f)

Connection id:		23
Server version:		8.0.22-13 Percona Server (GPL), Release 13, Revision 6f7822f
UNIX socket:		/opt/mysql_instances/magic8/mysql.sock
Binary data as:		Hexadecimal
Uptime:			10 min 45 sec

+----------+
| count(*) |
+----------+
|     4079 |
+----------+
1 row in set (0.00 sec)

/opt/mysql_templates/magic8/bin/mysql  Ver 8.0.22-13 for Linux on x86_64 (Percona Server (GPL), Release 13, Revision 6f7822f)

Connection id:		23
Server version:		8.0.22-13 Percona Server (GPL), Release 13, Revision 6f7822f
UNIX socket:		/opt/mysql_instances/magic8/mysql.sock
Binary data as:		Hexadecimal
Uptime:			10 min 45 sec

+----------+
| count(*) |
+----------+
|     4079 |
+----------+
1 row in set (0.00 sec)

No error of any type and no changes as for 5.7

Let us rollback to MySQL

/opt/mysql_templates/magic8/bin/mysql  Ver 8.0.22 for Linux on x86_64 (MySQL Community Server - GPL)

Connection id:		18
Server version:		8.0.22 MySQL Community Server - GPL
UNIX socket:		/opt/mysql_instances/magic8/mysql.sock
Binary data as:		Hexadecimal
Uptime:			19 sec

+----------+
| count(*) |
+----------+
|     4079 |
+----------+
1 row in set (0.00 sec)

/opt/mysql_templates/magic8/bin/mysql  Ver 8.0.22 for Linux on x86_64 (MySQL Community Server - GPL)

Connection id:		18
Server version:		8.0.22 MySQL Community Server - GPL
UNIX socket:		/opt/mysql_instances/magic8/mysql.sock
Binary data as:		Hexadecimal
Uptime:			19 sec

+----------+
| count(*) |
+----------+
|     4079 |
+----------+
1 row in set (0.00 sec)

Perfect and no issue.

Let us now try MariaDB

210308 09:13:34 mysqld_safe Starting mariadbd daemon with databases from /opt/mysql_instances/magic8/data
2021-03-08  9:13:35 0 [ERROR] /opt/mysql_templates/magic8/bin/mariadbd: Error while setting value 'index_merge=on,index_merge_union=on,index_merge_sort_union=on,index_merge_intersection=on,engine_condition_pushdown=on,index_condition_pushdown=on,mrr=on,mrr_cost_based=on,block_nested_loop=on,batched_key_access=off,materialization=on,semijoin=on,loosescan=on,firstmatch=on,duplicateweedout=on,subquery_materialization_cost_based=on,use_index_extensions=on,condition_fanout_filter=on,derived_merge=on' to 'optimizer_switch'
210308 09:13:35 mysqld_safe mysqld from pid file /opt/mysql_instances/magic8/mysqld.pid ended

210308 09:13:34 mysqld_safe Starting mariadbd daemon with databases from /opt/mysql_instances/magic8/data
2021-03-08  9:13:35 0 [ERROR] /opt/mysql_templates/magic8/bin/mariadbd: Error while setting value 'index_merge=on,index_merge_union=on,index_merge_sort_union=on,index_merge_intersection=on,engine_condition_pushdown=on,index_condition_pushdown=on,mrr=on,mrr_cost_based=on,block_nested_loop=on,batched_key_access=off,materialization=on,semijoin=on,loosescan=on,firstmatch=on,duplicateweedout=on,subquery_materialization_cost_based=on,use_index_extensions=on,condition_fanout_filter=on,derived_merge=on' to 'optimizer_switch'
210308 09:13:35 mysqld_safe mysqld from pid file /opt/mysql_instances/magic8/mysqld.pid ended

Ok let see if I remove the optimizer settings:

2021-03-08  9:14:53 0 [ERROR] InnoDB: Invalid flags 0x4800 in /opt/mysql_instances/magic8/data/ibdata1
2021-03-08  9:14:53 0 [ERROR] InnoDB: Plugin initialization aborted with error Data structure corruption
2021-03-08  9:14:53 0 [Note] InnoDB: Starting shutdown...
2021-03-08  9:14:53 0 [ERROR] Plugin 'InnoDB' init function returned error.
2021-03-08  9:14:53 0 [ERROR] Plugin 'InnoDB' registration as a STORAGE ENGINE failed.
2021-03-08  9:14:53 0 [Note] Plugin 'FEEDBACK' is disabled.
2021-03-08  9:14:53 0 [ERROR] Could not open mysql.plugin table: "Table 'mysql.plugin' doesn't exist". Some plugins may be not loaded
2021-03-08  9:14:53 0 [ERROR] /opt/mysql_templates/magic8/bin/mariadbd: unknown variable 'auto-generate-certs=TRUE'
2021-03-08  9:14:53 0 [ERROR] Aborting
210308 09:14:53 mysqld_safe mysqld from pid file /opt/mysql_instances/magic8/mysqld.pid ended

2021-03-08  9:14:53 0 [ERROR] InnoDB: Invalid flags 0x4800 in /opt/mysql_instances/magic8/data/ibdata1
2021-03-08  9:14:53 0 [ERROR] InnoDB: Plugin initialization aborted with error Data structure corruption
2021-03-08  9:14:53 0 [Note] InnoDB: Starting shutdown...
2021-03-08  9:14:53 0 [ERROR] Plugin 'InnoDB' init function returned error.
2021-03-08  9:14:53 0 [ERROR] Plugin 'InnoDB' registration as a STORAGE ENGINE failed.
2021-03-08  9:14:53 0 [Note] Plugin 'FEEDBACK' is disabled.
2021-03-08  9:14:53 0 [ERROR] Could not open mysql.plugin table: "Table 'mysql.plugin' doesn't exist". Some plugins may be not loaded
2021-03-08  9:14:53 0 [ERROR] /opt/mysql_templates/magic8/bin/mariadbd: unknown variable 'auto-generate-certs=TRUE'
2021-03-08  9:14:53 0 [ERROR] Aborting
210308 09:14:53 mysqld_safe mysqld from pid file /opt/mysql_instances/magic8/mysqld.pid ended

No way to have it working unless a logical dump

Summarizing

As for MySQL 5.7 once I have the instance built with MySQL 8.0.22 I can move to Percona 8.0.22 and roll back with no issues. Moving to MariaDB is not possible at all unless a full LOGICAL dump, which I really want to see how long it could take when you have TeraBytes of data.

Another weirdo  

While I was working with MariaDB I also review the documentation and my eyes were capture by this (https://mariadb.com/docs/reference/es/system-variables/innodb_purge_threads/) 

“WoW”, I thought, “DYNAMIC settings for innodb_purge_threads this is cool”. Let me try it.

/opt/mysql_templates/mariadb-10.5.9-linux-systemd-x86_64/bin/mysql  Ver 15.1 Distrib 10.5.9-MariaDB, for Linux (x86_64) using readline 5.1

Connection id:		7
Server:			MariaDB
Server version:		10.5.9-MariaDB MariaDB Server
UNIX socket:		/opt/mysql_instances/maria105/mysql.sock
Uptime:			8 min 14 sec


(root@localhost:pm) [(none)]>set global innodb_purge_threads=10;
ERROR 1238 (HY000): Variable 'innodb_purge_threads' is a read only variable
(root@localhost:pm) [(none)]>

/opt/mysql_templates/mariadb-10.5.9-linux-systemd-x86_64/bin/mysql  Ver 15.1 Distrib 10.5.9-MariaDB, for Linux (x86_64) using readline 5.1

Connection id:		7
Server:			MariaDB
Server version:		10.5.9-MariaDB MariaDB Server
UNIX socket:		/opt/mysql_instances/maria105/mysql.sock
Uptime:			8 min 14 sec


(root@localhost:pm) [(none)]>set global innodb_purge_threads=10;
ERROR 1238 (HY000): Variable 'innodb_purge_threads' is a read only variable
(root@localhost:pm) [(none)]>

Whaaat?? 

Then I realized I was on the page of “Enterprise Documentation”. Checking with the community version https://mariadb.com/kb/en/innodb-system-variables/#innodb_purge_threads innodb_purge_threads is still NOT dynamic, and after checking even more I also found Innodb_log_file_size, same story.

I was very badly impressed by this, for several reasons but want to mention the two most important:

1. MariaDB is declaring over and over to be the one truly open source and community oriented. But where is the support for the community here?
2. Is InnoDB not owned by Oracle? Isn't MariaDB using it because Oracle released it under the GPLv2? So why are they modifying the code and not returning it to the open source community? I am not an expert in legal things, but that sounds to me an infringement  of the license.

Conclusions

Drop-in replacement has a very specific meaning, and it must be used with caution. It also brings several strings attached, one of these is that replacing binaries is not a one way only solution. Attaching the term limited to drop-in as in MariaDB documentation, it is not correct, it still evokes an inapplicable concept and can be seen as misleading advertising.  

As we can see the only real drop-in replacement for MySQL is Percona Server, MariaDB is not even close to it, too many changes in the configuration file, and of course the need to go for a logical dump is not even remotely the right way to go. 

In short MariaDB is obviously a different product, as already stated by many in different articles, that is diverging more and more. 

The only reason for which MariaDB continues to play the drop-in game with MySQL, for me,  is because they continue to use the traction MySQL has on the community and the market, to attract customers. They also absorb from the work done by Oracle and Percona but as shown with innodb_purge_threads/innodb_log_file_size, they do not hesitate to keep significant features only for Enterprise version, without sharing with the community. 

As said many times, MariaDB has huge minds in development, starting from Monty down to any level of developer/DBA. We must recognize and respect that, as well we must recognize the great work they do at technical level.

I would love to see more collaboration, but I also understand the need to be something different to survive as a company. 

What I cannot accept is when we have claims that are not real like the drop-in replacement (also if limited), or even worse the case of innodb_purge_threads/innodb_log_file_size. 

That is wrong and as a strong advocate of open source and a lover of the MySQL/MariaDB community I feel I need to voice my concern. 

Great MySQL to all 

Reference

https://www.percona.com/resources/webinars/differences-between-mariadb%C2%AE-and-mysql%C2%AE

https://mariadb.com/docs/reference/es/system-variables/innodb_purge_threads/

https://mariadb.com/kb/en/innodb-system-variables/#innodb_purge_threads

https://mariadb.com/kb/en/mariadb-vs-mysql-compatibility/